Photo Credit: Marcus Ingram/Getty Images for ESPN
What began as a fairy tale in front of the cameras has ended in heartbreak behind closed doors. Lydia Gonzalez, known from season five of Love Is Blind, has officially filed for divorce from Milton Johnson after nearly three years of marriage, citing a series of issues that quietly unraveled their once-promising romance.
On the What’s the Reality? podcast, Lydia opened up for the first time about the breakdown of their relationship, revealing that problems began
just six months after their televised wedding. “At the beginning, everything was beautiful,” she reflected. “It was a fairy tale.” But as reality set in, their love story started to look less like a dream and more like a cautionary tale.
Lydia described emotional distance, lack of support, and troubling behavior on Milton’s part—including alleged flirtations with other women and staying in contact with an ex—as key contributors to the divorce. Even when she confronted him about the rumors, Lydia claims he turned the tables, questioning her trust instead of addressing the issue.
Her diagnosis with fibromyalgia added another layer of difficulty, as she struggled with chronic illness while also feeling unsupported in the home. Still, Lydia insists that the age difference—she’s 33, he’s 26—was not to blame. Rather, it was the absence of emotional maturity and communication that ultimately tore them apart.
Perhaps the most shocking revelation was Milton’s reported demand for a non-disclosure agreement before signing the divorce papers. Lydia’s
response? Silence no more. “I’ve been quiet for too long,” she said. “I needed to share my thoughts and my experience.”
Despite the heartbreak, Lydia hasn’t lost her sense of hope or her gratitude for what the relationship taught her. “He was the first man
to love me, and that is not something small,” she admitted, acknowledging that he will always hold a piece of her heart.
Now, she’s focused on healing and growth, drawing strength from her struggles. “There’s been a lot of grief, heartbreak, a lot of growth. But I’m here,” she said, her voice carrying both pain and power. “And I’m so proud of my strength and what it keeps proving to be—my resilience in life.”
Lydia’s story is a reminder that love, while beautiful, is not always enough. But self-worth, truth, and resilience? Those are the real forever things.
